The Daily Edge uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

The burning question*: Do you hover on outside lane on dual carriageway?

This and every Monday, let TheJournal.ie distract you from the ‘serious’ news with one of life’s REAL dilemmas. (*not really)

Whatever about which lane you should be in, THIS is definitely against the rules of the road...
Whatever about which lane you should be in, THIS is definitely against the rules of the road...
Image: Jeff Moore/Jeff Moore/Empics Entertainment/PA Images

WE KNOW HOW you feel. The week looms ahead – but you will still have a lot on your plate.

So do like we do here in TheJournal.ie HQ and get stuck into a serious debate on one of life’s most pressing questions…

This week… In the comments section of last week’s Burning Question, John O’Mahony threw up another little conundrum. This was what he asked:

Off topic but what about people driving by default on the outside lane on a two lane dual carriageway? I invariably stay in the left lane and find myself overtaking those in the right lane who presumably took it because they thought it would be quicker. Perhaps The Daily Edge should have a poll on it.

So what do you think? Should you…

A. Only use the outside (right-hand) lane on a dual carriageway/motorway for overtaking, or…

(Image: David Jones/PA Archive/Press Association Images)

B. Should you drive there if you want to?

(Image: Lewis Whyld/PA Archive/Press Association Images)

NOTE: According to Irish road traffic legislation, you must move back to the left lane following an overtake. Remaining in the overtake lane on the right will land you with one penalty point and a €60 fine.

Vote here: Should the outside (right-hand) lane on a dual carriageway be used…


Poll Results:





What burning question divides your household/work colleagues/friends? If you want to see yours featured in this series, leave us a comment or email us at tips[at]thejournal.ie

See previous entries in The Burning Question*>

Read next:

Comments (139 Comments)

  • I drive for a living and experience outside lane drivers regularly but it’s nothing compared to the amount of middle lane drivers on the M50.

    Reply
    • Middle lane drivers are the worst. Why are we such a bad nation of drivers??? The middle lane is not for lumbering along in!!

      Reply
    • Nothing is more annoying than that and lorries overtaking lorries!! I think it’s down to years of poor testing and allowing people to drive unaccompanied on provisionals

      Reply
    • In picture above there is absolute nothing wrong with using middle lane. The majority of Irish drivers don’t use the two second rule which makes it dangerous to merge onto motorway from slip road.Centre lane can be used if driving at speed limit.

      Reply
    • Eire2011. So your saying 66% of those in picture are wrong. With traffic at slow pace on motorway you think everybody should use inside lane?

      Reply
    • damian 16/04/12 #

      Especially on the M50, the amount of middle lane hoggers is ridiculous! In the M50 case, it’s nearly worse than outside lane hoggers…

      The other day for example there was someone sitting doing 80 KM/H in the middle lane. There was a queue of cars on the driving/inside lane, a queue of cars behind the car at fault in the middle lane, and neither laneful of cars could get out to overtake in the overtaking/outside lane to get past as there was already a stream of cars in it!

      There were people bit by bit undertaking in the leftmost/driving lane… It was just waiting for a major accident to happen! Eventuall after about 10 minutes of being stuck in that, someone blared a horn/flashed at them to move and the blockage cleared….. can’t stand idiots like that!!!! grrrr!

      Reply
  • Roundabouts are another area where many people haven’t a clue what lane they should be in. The RSA have ads on tv now trying to show drivers how to use them properly.

    Reply
    • Not defending bad driving habits but on the roundabout issue local council have allot to answer for, I drive allot with work and I find allot of roundabouts in different towns with wrong road markings, effectively breaking the rules of the road.

      Reply
    • Completely but there is no consistency in lane markings on roundabouts either, can be very confusing when at one roundabout straight is the accepted left lane and then the next it’s moved into the right!

      Reply
    • Ppp
      M

      Reply
    • mattoid 16/04/12 #

      @ Joseph, That’s why we have road markings. The problem is that many drivers don’t even look for them, or just ignore them.
      @Damien, I thought that the rules of the road state that road markings take precedence, ie. that you stay in the left lane to go straight ahead at a roundabout unless directed otherwise by road markings.

      Reply
    • My biggest gripe with roundabouts is not the markings, but the fact that a large percentage of drivers use no indicators at all when using roundabouts. Crazy. You take your life in your hands when you use the Liffey Valley roundabout. This is not down to a lack of education on how to use a roundabout, but down to pure laziness.

      Reply
    • @mattoid I understand that completely but most of the markings are not on the floor until you’re almost on the roundabout which doesn’t help. Also people in the right lane who edge so far forward you can’t see past them when you are taking the first exit your lane may well be free and you have to stay because they are blocking your view, is also quite intimidating when you are on a small roundabout and they do this, you wonder if they are going to jump out on top of you!

      Reply
  • ok everyone here is voting ‘only for overtaking’. So why don’t you actually do it then! God Ireland is dreadful for motorway driving, people really don’t understand the outside lane is only for overtaking

    Reply
  • There are many drivers who sit in the outside lane doing 80km an hour and they refuse to pull into the left lane to let others pass. It is so f**king irritating.

    Reply
  • On the M50 quite a bit and the number of shit head drivers is unreal. It’s an overtaking lane so if someone is driving past you on your left you’re in the wrong lane.
    Don’t get me started on roundabouts, why would you go into the left lane to turn right, you wouldn’t do it on a straight road so why do it on a roundabout.

    Reply
  • Yvie M 16/04/12 #

    One of my pet hates. Folk hogging the over taking lane. There’s always some eejit just sitting there… Idiots!!

    Reply
    • All you have to do is overtake them on inside lane. Anyone who gives thumbs down for this comment should never drive.

      Reply
    • Really? I’d say someone who advocates breaking the rules of the road should never drive

      Reply
    • mattoid 16/04/12 #

      @Sean, I think that’s the most ridiculous comment in this whole thread. On the off-chance that you weren’t trolling, someone should let you know that undertaking is not only illegal, its also one of the most dangerously unpredictable manoevres you can perform – there’s a reason why its illegal!
      I can understand frustration building up when you’re stuck behind a lane hogger, but undertaking is a stupid response.
      So yes, I did thumb down your comment ;)

      Reply
    • Mattoid. Page 123 on Rules of the Road “overtaking only on the right, unless traffic is moving in slow moving queues and the traffic queue on your right is travelling more slowly than you are” Wouldn’t 40 or 50 in an 80kmh be a slow moving queue?

      Reply
    • Oh come on now you are just being obstinate for the sake of it, no its not slow moving, that caveat is designed for heavy traffic situations be it by congestion or an incident where you are crawling and often can’t change lane due to traffic volume.

      Reply
  • Wrecks my head when people hover on the outside(overtaking) lane especially donkeys who are driving under the speed limit

    Reply
    • Donkeys driving under the speed limit? I’m assuming that’s just a turn of phrase. I have never been behind a donkey that’s breaking the limit…… Woof

      Reply
    • Sean mcavinue you drive in the left lane in this country so why are you saying it is ok to drive in middle lane??? That is the problem with drivers in this country. We drive in the LEFT lane. Watch the ad on the tv!!!!!

      Reply
    • eire2011 16/04/12 #

      Sean mcavinue the problem is not when you are stuck in a traffic jam but you said it is ok to drive in middle lane. It’s not we drive in left lane over here. You can sit in traffic jam in any lane unless you want a 10 mile tail back!!!!

      Reply
  • Rob 16/04/12 #

    Motorway driving in general is just so so bad in ireland!!

    a) hovering in outside lane
    b) aggressively tail gating (albeit due to a above)
    c) failing to move out a lane to allow traffic to merge
    d) overtaking in inside lanes (albeit due to a above)
    e) randomly hogging the middle lane cos you think you’re driving at an average speed.
    f) failing to maintain a consistent speed – ie overtaking and then randomly slowing down and forcing me to overtake you again – only for you to wake up and overtake me again!!

    theres more i’m sure but if we could fix this i’d be happy enough!

    Reply
  • I promise this is not off-topic and is closely related. I have driven in a lot of countries world-wide but only in Ireland have I experience so many drivers who cannot allow themselves to be overtaken. On a motorway they speed up when you get into the overtaking lane. On rural roads it’s like they would prefer to get you killed than let you pass. Is this uniquely Irish?

    Reply
  • Yep! you do get the “self styled” police hovering below the speed limit on the outside lane.

    Reply
    • Almost as bad again is when you are genuinely overtaking at 75/80mph and you get the luanatic fly up to you at approaching 100mph who then proceed to sit an inch off your rear bumper until you have cleared the slower cars and pull in, do they not get that at that speed you need reacting/stopping distance? Or are they deluded enough to think that a pile up could not possibly happen to them?

      Reply
  • I get as frustrated as everyone else at the prospect of being stuck behind a slow moving vehicle in the right hand lane.

    However, there are two things I refuse to do in situations like that:

    1) Drive like an idiot tail gating the car in front of me
    2) Cave into pressure from the idiot who is tail gating me for the crime of not tail gating the car in front of me

    More often than not, the slow driver is several cars ahead causing problems for a whole line of traffic. Driving like a moron doesn’t get anyone home faster.

    Reply
    • I agree what you have said but those slower drivers in the over taking lane are obstructing the flow of traffic and hence committing an offence.

      Undertaking them if possible is illegal so your screwed, people caught in the over taking lane obstructing the flow of traffic should have penalty points and a fine.

      They would soon enough stop doing it and also they cause road rage, which in turn potentially can cause death or serious injury.

      Going to slow is as dangerous as the opposite!

      Reply
    • It’s not an offence. On the Dual carriageway both lanes are the same. Unlike the Motorway there’s no minimum speed limit and there’s nothing to say they have to stick to the left. .

      Reply
    • What do you mean by the use of the plural in “those slow drivers”? Do you think the car doing the tail gating is the only driver who has a right to use the overtaking lane? He’s also a slow driver, just like all of the other cars stuck behind the leading vehicle.

      The car at the front is the only one choosing to drive slowly in the right hand lane, all of the others are attempting to overtake the cars in the left hand lane and can’t due to the right hand lane being blocked.

      Reply
    • @ Jane Ward

      You obviously have not read the rules of the road

      Reply
  • So if 89% use the outside lane only for overtaking where are all these people hogging the outside lane coming from?
    Thanks to The Daily Edge for taking up my suggestion :-)

    Reply
  • The M50 is great since they revamped it so I don’t want to knock it but it’s really only a toy motorway. It’s got a 100km/h speed limit (not 120km/h as on a proper motorway) because there are so many junctions on it. Junctions are far closer together on the M50 and I think it’s for this reason that people tend to live in the middle lane. Every km or two they’d be pulling out from the left hand lane to the middle lane to allow traffic merge at a junction so they just stay in the middle. I can understand that to be honest. But I cannot understand people plodding along at any speed in the outer overtaking lane. That’s just nonsensically stupid and shows a blatant ignorance of the rules, complete unawareness of what’s going on around them and disregard for other road users.

    Reply
  • Try the M1 and the aggression of yellow plated drivers who think it is their god given right to attempt the land speed records, F*cking morons.

    Use it to overtake and get back into the normal lane.

    I also drive for a living and I see the standard of driving here on this island as a whole is bad…

    Southern Irish drivers breaking the law enmass up North and vice versa down south…

    Maybe bringing in motorway driving to the driving test should be implemented..

    Reply
  • Anybody who voted B should be made re-sit their driving test. Worst habit ever!

    Reply
  • Biggles 16/04/12 #

    It’s hardly surprising that people end up in the wrong lane on the motorway, the driving test in the past (it has hopefully changed now to include theory for learners on how to drive on a motorway) never included or covered the motorway and my first time on the motorway was after passing my test, probably one of the most terrifying experiences of my life with trucks & cars driving up your tail, total chaos & most drivers seem to think that they can drive in whatever lane suits them!it’s crazy that one day you’re a learner not allowed on the motorway and as soon as you pass your test you’re allowed on the motorway with no experience. The Daily Edge how about a survey on when you’re allowed to enter yellow boxes?It’s another area most drivers don’t seem to have a clue about.

    Reply
  • You know who you are !!!!

    Stand up and admit it like a man (or perhaps a woman….)

    You are the bane of the life of decent motorway drivers. The clowns who tap their brake lights, and the gang who never use a rear view mirror should be banned from motorways

    Reply
  • The M50 is absolutely comical. People just will not use the far left lane at all ! Ever ! Trucks are a big issue too on two laned Motorways! They are NOT ALLOWED into the right hand lane but are constantly in there and it’s never stopped !

    Reply
  • Next time you’re on a busy motorway and approaching an on ramp, take note of all the cars that come down the on ramp and cut straight across into the overtaking lane! We have an obsession in this country about getting into the overtaking lane.

    Ironically usually the quickest lane in rush hour is the inside lane, because all the muppets are in the other lane.

    Reply
  • Worse still and very dangerous is when overtaking, at considerable speed in comparison to slow vehicles, some drivers just pull out in front just as I’m about to pass.
    I have near misses everyday.
    Also why can’t we have a penalty system for slow drivers.
    They are a total hazard and oblivious to their environment and all the bad karma building up behind them.
    I was in a 50 convoy yesterday at 60k on a main road contra flow, because of one shitty Nissan Micra.
    The risky overtaking was inevitable.
    Maybe Leo could start meddling on this area.

    Reply
  • People that drive in the overtaking lane are the same ones that refer to it as the ‘fast lane’, why would I waste my time driving in the ‘slow lane’

    Reply
    • mattoid 16/04/12 #

      Probably the same ones who don’t bother indicating because “sure don’t I already know where I’m going?”

      Reply
    • There is no such thing as a fast lane in this country, lane two of a motorway is not a fast lane.

      We have slow lanes in this country at certain steep locations but it’s not lane one of the motorway.

      Until the Garda start pulling for bad lane use on the M50 then people will keep on doing it the same way. Prob can’t fine anyone but they can delay them for 10mins while they ‘check’ the vehicle.

      I’ve seen cars on Lane 1 of the motorway go faster then those in the 2nd and 3rd lanes, that is just wrong.

      Reply
  • I’d say 85% of those people are lying

    Reply
  • I havn’t read any of the comments above, but what do people find when using a roundabout. Which lane do you use when you want to take the 2nd exit. Left or Right. I find I am constantly being cut up by knobs who dont know the rules of the road for using roundabouts

    Reply
    • Unless you’re turning right, or road markings indicate otherwise, you should be in the left lane. However, on a dual carriageway it’s usually acceptable to use either, provided of course you exit the roundabout in the same lane you entered.

      Reply
    • @Aaron You’re right of course, but very few people seem to be aware of the fact that you can’t turn right from the left lane on a round-about! It’s an unbelievable dangerous and stupid thing to do and yet extremely common to see in Ireland.

      Reply
  • Thanks for bringing up this issue. Please overtake and go back into the slow lane. It’s that simple so why do so many Irish drivers sit in the outside lane and ignore the mile of traffic trying to pass them. This is the worst country in Europe for this offence

    Reply
  • Driving in France is such a pleasure because people there have the cop on to use the overtaking lane for overtaking and nothing else. When they see how the Irish drive they must think we’re a nation of ignorant bog trotters! I’d have to say I’d agree and I’m Irish!

    Reply
  • censored 16/04/12 #

    Ireland is gradually bringing in the “drive on the right” rule in order to align with other EU countries. Didn’t you get the directive?

    Reply
  • Dual carriageways, eg the n11 stillorgan dual carriageway, and motorways, eg the m50, have different rules. dual carriageways are dual carriageways, there is no overtaking lane. motorways are SUPPOSED to have overtaking lanes but how is that supposed to work with three lanes? i find myself in the third lane of the m50 a lot doing 110 and overtaking strings of traffic doing 90! i’ll be sh**ged if im sittin at the back of a line of cars all trundling along at 90 in the middle lane! if the road is pretty much empty i’ll be in the left lane always but as ppl generally dont know what they’re doing decent drivers can’t use the motorways as they’re supposed to be either!

    Reply
  • Viv Egan 16/04/12 #

    I cant understand all the right lane hoggers but the middle lane hoggers drive me nutty too… It means if you’re driving along in the left lane as obilged and you want to over take, you most likely have to change over two lanes. Another reason why these people stay in the middle… If everyone could just drive as per the rules, the m50 would be happier experience!

    Reply
  • Im guessing from the results above the people that camp in the middle lane of the motorway, dont use computers much either. And WORSE dont read the journal!!
    Only slightly off topic here Journal, But another burning topic you might consider polling on is Merging. The consensus is Irish people cant merge! Is it out of politeness and the fear of being called a skipper ( aka queue skipper in school) or is it lack of knowledge? People seem to pick a spot , stop the car and wait for a written invitation to enter the lane they intend entering! Again its seen most on the M50 and slows the whole thing down. Here is your chance to get a definitive answer once and for all!
    just saying.

    Reply
  • howzat 16/04/12 #

    Other pet hates
    Slow women drivers 2 mm from the windscreen with rigid hands on the wheel
    60+ men driving in the near lane while traffic is merging
    Boy donkeys increasing their speed when your overtaking them
    Women in their twenties on their mobiles driving 17 miles an hour hogging two lanes
    50 year old men in mercs driving slower because they listening to lyric fm
    Taxis all of them all the time
    Airport buses who pull out in front of you cause they are bigger and are on a bonus arrival time
    Women parking in school runs in the middle of the road
    People who don’t let you put because it might add 8 seconds to their journey
    Truck drivers from Monaghan and Meath who speed up at merging traffic just for the buzz
    Northern reg cars that go up bus lanes
    Growl
    Growl

    Reply
  • How about JCBs and tractors driving in the middle lane on Cork’s ring roads. See it every day!

    Reply
  • So if 89% use the outside lane only for overtaking where are all these people hogging the outside lane coming from?
    Thanks to The Daily Edge for taking up my suggestion for a poll :-)

    Reply
  • jimbo 16/04/12 #

    When your already in the right lane going at limit or more. And some arsehole comes up behind you in an Audi that thinks he owns the motorway

    Reply
  • howzat 16/04/12 #

    Bull

    Reply
  • Part of the problem on the roads is that we see speed LIMITS as a goal that we have to at minimum achieve. As for the comment above calling people who drive below the speed limit as ‘Donkeys’ You personafy what is wrong with the mentality on Irish roads.

    Reply
    • On an N or an R road I agree with you completely but on a clear motorway it is more dangerous to drive below the limit than slightly above it, the amount of drivers I’ve come up to on the M6, albeit in the correct lane usually, doing 40mph is is scary when everyone around them is doing around 70mph, is asking for trouble

      Reply
  • After reading all these comments I find it hard to believe the amount of expert drivers who think it is illegal to undertake if overtaking lane is at slower speed ie 40kmh in a 60kmh limit. Where one driver dictates the speed of the traffic behind.

    Reply
    • mattoid 16/04/12 #

      Now I know you’re trolling…

      Reply
    • mattoid 16/04/12 #

      Especially for you Sean, from the Rules of the Road:
      “Overtake only on the right, unless traffic is travelling in slow moving queues and the traffic queue on your right is travelling more slowly than you are.”

      Reply
    • Mattoid. You should get on to the RSA and tell them buses and taxis who drive 60kmh while undertaking other traffic moving slower are breaking the Rules of the Road. And stick to the bus!

      Reply
    • They are in a separated bus lane that we aren’t allowed in and so are hardly likely to pull out in front of them unlike a car that’s in the last place you would expect it, your far side blind spot, in s lane you may wish to merge into and speeding up.

      Reply
    • Joseph. On many occasions esp along North Strand inbound at 10am when it’s open to all traffic I have entered the out of use bus lane and have undertaken other traffic all the way into Amiens St with taxis and busses in front and behind yet if I am in the wrong as the majority of experts say then rules of the road need a serious review.

      Reply
    • Sean is actually correct. It not illegal to undertake if the lane on your right is moving slower than you are or is obstructed. What rules are ye reading.

      Reply
    • mattoid 17/04/12 #

      Michael, as has been quoted in more than one place on this thread, the rules of the road clearly state: “Overtake only on the right, unless traffic is travelling in slow moving queues and the traffic queue on your right is travelling more slowly than you are.”
      ie. the only time you can legally overtake on an inside lane is when there is a SLOW MOVING QUEUE, such as a tailback from roadworks or an accident etc..
      In any other situation it is illegal to use the inside lane for overtaking, and if anyone has told you otherwise they have misled you. If your driving instructor has told you otherwise you should be asking for your money back!
      If some idiot is hogging the outside lane the only thing you can legally do is suck it up and wait for them to move, however frustrating it is.

      Reply
    • Sean the north strand also isnt a motorway, motorways have their own separate set of rules and that is what we have all been referring to above.

      Reply
  • I drive in the lane closest to the exit I know I’ll have to take further up the road.

    Reply
  • If I’m not in anyone else’s way, I don’t see the problem.

    Much safer to stay there than have to keep changing lanes in and out to pass the toss pots doing 80.

    Reply
  • Whilst we’re on the subject…how about the total inability to sensibly merge at an on ramp when there’s a traffic jam. So many mornings at J4 on the m1 southbound I sit back and let a nice big space open up….still they pile right up to the end of the merge lane.

    Reply

Add New Comment